
Penyelesaian Sengketa
Islamic finance and sharia business disputes at the Religious Court
Pendampingan sengketa akad syariah, seperti murabahah, musyarakah, mudharabah, ijarah, asuransi syariah, dan pembiayaan bank syariah, melalui musyawarah, mediasi, Basyarnas, atau gugatan di Pengadilan Agama, termasuk gu…
← All ALLMAR Law & Permit services
Short answer
Sharia economic disputes, including Islamic bank financing, are heard by the Religious Court under Article 49 of Law 3/2006 and Article 55 of Law 21/2008, unless the contract chooses another method such as sharia arbitration. Claims may follow the small claims or ordinary track under Supreme Court Regulation 14/2016, after mandatory mediation.
Sharia economic disputes, such as default on a murabahah financing from an Islamic bank or a profit-sharing quarrel in a musyarakah partnership, are heard by the Religious Court (Pengadilan Agama), not the District Court. This jurisdiction comes from Article 49 of Law 3/2006 amending the Religious Courts Law and, for Islamic banking, Article 55 of Law 21/2008. Parties may still choose another route if their contract says so, such as negotiation, mediation or sharia arbitration. Procedure is set by Supreme Court Regulation 14/2016, which offers a small claims track and an ordinary track.
Jurisdiction
Article 55(1) of Law 21/2008 sends Islamic banking disputes to the Religious Courts; Article 55(2) allows another method agreed in the contract, provided it is consistent with sharia principles (Article 55(3)). Constitutional Court Decision 93/PUU-X/2012 removed the elucidation that once allowed District Court litigation, so the remaining alternatives are non-court methods such as negotiation, mediation and arbitration. Where a valid Basyarnas or other sharia arbitration clause exists, arbitrators decide the merits, and the Religious Court handles enforcement and annulment (Article 13(2) and (3) of Regulation 14/2016).
Procedure
Cases may be filed as a small claim or an ordinary claim (Article 2). Small claims may be lodged orally, in writing or online, using a court form with parties, facts, relief and legalised documents (Articles 3 and 4), within the value limit in force when filed. Ordinary claims follow civil procedure unless the Regulation says otherwise (Article 7), before at least three judges certified in sharia economics (Article 9), after compulsory mediation (Article 10). Judgments must state the sharia principles relied on (Article 5), so pleadings should cite the contract and relevant fatwa, not conventional interest formulas. Enforcement of judgments and of security rights under sharia contracts lies with the Religious Court (Article 13(1)).
How ALLMAR handles it
- The contract, dispute clause and payment figures are read first to fix the right forum.
- Strategy and fees go into a written legal services agreement up front. Court deposits are paid as the court sets, and the client covers VAT and income tax on our fee separately.
- The case is run in the chosen forum by ALLMAR Law & Permit advocates: demand letters, restructuring proposals, pleadings, arbitration requests, mediation and hearings.
- A report follows each hearing, with no promised outcome.
- Files are handed over with post-judgment deadlines, such as appeal, settlement compliance or enforcement.
Checklist before you start
- The contract and every addendum.
- Instalment schedule and payment proof.
- Profit-sharing reports for partnership contracts.
- Warning letters and correspondence.
- Collateral documents.
- Special power of attorney.
Common mistakes
- Filing at the District Court.
- Ignoring an arbitration clause.
- Claiming interest instead of margin, profit ratio or fee under the contract.
- Treating mediation as a formality.
After it is done
Carry out the settlement or final judgment as written. If the other side does not comply, apply to the Religious Court for enforcement, including against collateral. Once paid, ask for roya or fiduciary deregistration.
What you get
- Telaah akad dari sisi hukum dan prinsip syariah
- Pilihan jalur yang tepat: musyawarah, Basyarnas, atau Pengadilan Agama
- Gugatan atau jawaban gugatan yang tersusun
- Pendampingan sampai eksekusi putusan
FAQ
Why not file at the District Court?
Article 49 of Law 3/2006 places sharia economic matters under the Religious Courts, and Article 55(1) of Law 21/2008 confirms this for Islamic banking. A District Court may decline jurisdiction.
Can non-Muslims litigate at the Religious Court?
Yes. What matters is the sharia contract the parties chose, not their religion.
What if the contract has an arbitration clause?
Article 55(2) of Law 21/2008 allows resolution as agreed in the contract. A valid clause sends the merits to arbitrators, while enforcement and annulment of sharia arbitral awards lie with the Religious Court (Article 13(2) of Supreme Court Regulation 14/2016).
Is there a small claims track?
Yes. Low-value claims may be filed orally, in writing or electronically under a simplified procedure (Articles 3 and 4 of Regulation 14/2016), within the value limit set by current Supreme Court rules.
Can ALLMAR promise a win?
No. The result rests on the contract, the evidence and the judges. ALLMAR Law & Permit advocates prepare and conduct the case without promising any result.
